Estelle: The Geography of You and Me by Jen E. Smith

The Geography of You and Me by Jennifer E SmithThe Geography of You and Me by Jennifer E. Smith ( web | tweet )
Publication Date: April 15, 2014
Publisher: Little Brown/Poppy
Pages: 352
Target audience: Young adult
Keywords: New York City, travel, relationships with parents, long distance friendship/romance
Format read: ARC from Publisher via NetGalley. (Thanks!)

Summary: Owen and Lucy get stuck in an elevator together during a blackout in New York City. Once they are rescued, they explore the darkened (mostly) city and get to know each other. When they wake up the next morning, instead of picking up where they left off, Owen is off taking care of his dad and Lucy is off to (shockingly enough) meet her parents in London. Did their night of chatting, joking, and sharing mean anything more than just that? Owen and Lucy’s lives snowball into something new, maintaining the smallest amount of contact, yet still wondering if they will ever be in the same place again.

There are a few things I’ve come to expect from a Jennifer E. Smith novel: gorgeous prose, intimate friendships, family conflicts, and probably my favorite: lovely details to relish and collect along the way.

I’m so happy to say that The Geography of You and Me delivers in each and every way with the added bonus of a setting that starts off in my favorite place of all-time, New York City, and manages to move along to the West Coast and overseas in a way that made me want to book a plane ticket and explore the world immediately.

Do you remember the blackout in 2003? It was right before I left for college and one of my close friends and I were planning to go into the city after I got out of work. We wanted to see a show in an attempt to make as many memories as possible before we were apart for the first time in years. Well, it never happened. The lights went out in the store I was working in and I went home to no electricity — my plans for the evening totally changed.

My night was definitely not as memorable as Lucy and Owen’s. They spent the night wandering the city, getting to know each other, and looking up at the stars on the roof of their building. (It was their coolest refuge in the crazy heat of the summer.) What I loved most was that their time together wasn’t memorable because something physical happened, but because they shared something — it was a night where they both would have been alone if they hadn’t been caught in the elevator together. (Owen’s dad was stuck in Coney Island, and Lucy’s parents were on vacation in London.) It was one night of so many inconveniences that seemed better than so many others strung together. I didn’t blame each of them for placing so much importance on it, for wondering if it meant as much to the other as it did to them.

I would have been in the same boat.

One magical night doesn’t erase the grieving process that Owen and his dad are going through since his mother died a few months ago. Nor does Lucy’s confusion about feeling excluded from her parents’ lives (and their lavish trips) and wanting so much to see more of the world. Something that really stood out to me were the relationships between each of the characters and their parents. When Owen and his dad decide to leave New York and road trip to their next destination, the two get this unheard of time together to make life work without a mom and a wife. I felt almost jealous of these memories they were making together, even when it was difficult and they didn’t know if each destination was their last.

On the other hand, Lucy had a lot of independence as a teenager. But her parents don’t consider her thoughts when they move her overseas to Edinburgh and her growth as a character has a lot to do with being open with her parents. It’s a difficult thing to do and while she settles as best she can in a new place, she’s sort of at war with this independent life she has been conditioned to have but also trying to figure out how to share her life with her parents and be close to them too.

Through all of this, Owen and Lucy don’t forget each other. There are postcards and emails. Infrequent, but they happen! Most importantly, they don’t let their affection for each other and curiosity about what the blackout night meant for them stop them from moving forward. New locations, new jobs, new schools, and new boyfriends and girlfriends. Life keeps happening, even if you can’t stop thinking about a certain person. The way they miss each other is never angsty or dramatic either… it feels incredibly natural — all due to Smith’s gorgeous and thoughtful writing.

Other standout parts: the realism and awkwardness of the San Francisco trip, an effectively written section where Smith gives us one sentence per chapter (I loved what this did to the pacing), and the depth of character development folded into the story. At one point, I stayed up way past my bedtime because I was in such a trance over Owen and Lucy’s story and I needed to know how it was all going to end.

The Geography of You and Me packed in everything I love so much about the young adult contemporary genre — a fully fleshed out story with two characters who are learning so much about themselves through their relationships with their parents and those special people who make an everlasting imprint in our lives.

Rather Be Reading Buy It Icon

Add to Goodreads | Buy on Amazon | Buy on B&N

P.S. I now know I need some kind of plan for future blackouts and keeping my cat safe. (Help!)

11 thoughts on “Estelle: The Geography of You and Me by Jen E. Smith

  1. Quinn @ Quinn's Book Nook says:

    I finished this one not too long ago. I liked it, and it was definitely what I expect from Jennifer E. Smith novels. My only quibble is that I wasn’t able to really connect to Lucy and Owen. I thought they were adorable and so cute, but I think the whole time I was reading it, I knew they weren’t real.

    I’m glad you liked this one, though. It sounds like you didn’t have the same kind of expierence during the 2003 blackout that Lucy and Owen did 🙂

  2. Hollie @ Music, Books and Tea says:

    I think you listed all my favourite things about Jennifer E. Smith’s novels in your review, and I’m so pleased that this one delivered too. I’ve been desperate to read it ever since I read the premise, there’s something quite awesome about the idea of two people thrown together in a blackout and that night having a bigger effect on them than they expected. It’s nice to see that they don’t stop living their lives because of one another too. Ugh, I’m seriously pining hard over this one now! Lovely review 🙂

  3. alice-jane says:

    I just started The Geography of You and Me and I like it so far! I’m glad that you found it so realistic, which definitely makes me want to finish the book sooner! I like how the characters seem more realistic, which was my problem with This Is What Happy Looks Like. I found This Is What Happy Looks Like cute and adorable, but that was it. Hopefully, The Geography of You and Me delivers and I’ll like it as much as you did.

  4. Meg says:

    Sounds like a really great read! I love novels that hop across different locations, and the idea of one magical evening is pretty appealing to me. Reminds me, in a different way, of “Nick & Norah’s Infinite Playlist.”

  5. Candice @ The Grown-Up YA says:

    Yay! I’m so glad this one was such a winner. I’ve been looking forward to it for a while. Love how JES incorporates so many different types of meetings in her books and this one sounds just so unique. Like a fantasy meet cute that COULD happen… but really only happens in rom coms. Can’t wait to read this myself! Great review!

  6. Alexa S. says:

    Your review for this book is absolutely GORGEOUS, E. I’m seriously obsessed with how perfectly worded it is. You definitely hit the nail on the head here. The Geography of You and Me was a wonderful read, and I loved it oh so much!

  7. Katy says:

    This one sounds pretty cute! I wasn’t sure it would be for me, but I feel like giving it a shot now. Their interactions, and the realism and a bit of awkwardness sounds like it’s enjoyable. The fact that they learn a lot about themselves makes it even better!

  8. Hannah @ So Obsessed With says:

    Oh, this sounds really good! I loved Statistical Probability but was a little on the fence about This is What Happy Looks Like (mostly because I thought it was fun and cute but ultimately not that memorable). This one sounds like it might be more up my alley, and it’s got your stamp of approval. I definitely need to give it a shot!

  9. Judith says:

    I was just kind of intrigued by this one before, but OMG IT SOUNDS AMAZING! I just love the sound of the story, and I think Jen E. Smith always writes books with amazing concepts. I actually thought it was going to be about one night, much like Statistical Probability was about one day, but I love that it’s longer than that. Can’t wait to get my hands on this one!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *