Rather Be Reading » A Young Adult Book Blog by Two Busy Girls Who Always Find Time For a Book

Masthead header

Estelle: One Man Guy by Michael Barakiva

One Man Guy by Michael BarakivaOne Man Guy by Michael Barakiva ( web )
Publication Date: May 27, 2014
Publisher: Farrar, Straus, Giroux (Macmillan Kids)
Pages: 272
Target audience: Young adult
Keywords: Armenian culture, LGBT, summer school, NYC, family
Format read: ARC from Publisher via NetGalley

Summary: When Alek’s parents spring summer school attendance on him so he can stay on the honors track next year, he’s totally bummed to be missing out on camp, hanging out with his best friend (the boisterous Becky!),  and the big family vacation. But things get interesting when Ethan, a notorious bad boy/skater kid, shows up in Alek’s algebra class and the two hit it off.

I don’t know if it’s possible for me to convey just how adorable One Man Guy is. But I’m going to try.

Alek is 14 and forced into summer school because his parents want him to stay on the honors track next year at school. He’s not a bad student. He’s had a hard time transitioning from middle school to high school, and can’t seem to get the hang of things. So instead of a summer of freedom & a family vacation, he’s stuck taking classes and doing homework.

If it hadn’t been for his parents’ meddling, he never would have ended up in algebra with Ethan, a kid with a reputation for being a troublemaker and slacker, but who also just saved his ass a few days ago when one of Ethan’s jerk friends tries to pick a fight with Alek. Alek is curious about Ethan, and it’s not until a particularly gutsy move on his part that the two spark a friendship.

Okay. One thing I really liked about One Man Guy is that Alek wasn’t someone who was soul searching about his sexuality. He mentions having girlfriends, and while he is pretty riveted with Ethan, he doesn’t know try to figure out what he means. He just goes with it. Letting go and defying his parents with secret trips to NYC gives him new insight into his feelings and what his relationship with Ethan really means to him.

Everything about Ethan and Alek’s transition from friendship to relationship felt natural. Ethan needed a dose of Alek’s responsibility and, in turn, Alek benefited from Ethan’s sense of adventure. Even if it went against everything his very strict parents trust him to do. But it was kind of fun to see Alek let loose and fall in love with Ethan AND New York City. (Um, their dates were adorable.)

Another great detail of the book was Alek’s family. They are Armenian, and his parents are very quick to dismiss “the silly Americans” who think baking from scratch means using a mix. His mom is also the kind of lady who will need to know all the details of the water served at your restaurant before she agrees to have that water. I loved their dialogue and how all of their personalities popped off the pages. There was this struggle to embrace old school ideals and assimilate to this day in this world. Alek thinks his parents are mostly unreasonable, and for a 14 year old kid, I could see that being true. It’s a whole other layer of pressure to be perfect at yet another thing. (Alek can never compete with his “angelic” older brother either.)

While One Man Guy felt a bit preachy at times and has a good amount of expository passages (a shame because the dialogue was so fresh), I loved watching Alek have this turning point summer. He learned a ton about himself, the people around him, and even got a brand new wardrobe. (I couldn’t help but mention this — I love shopping and mini-makeovers!) It’s also nice to see that while One Man Guy is a book about sexuality that there are so many other plotlines that come into play here. Also a quick shout out to Alek’s best friend, Becky, who loves classic films (and is a supportive and outgoing gal). So fun!

Did I mention this a debut from Barakiva? Can’t wait to see what he does next!

rather be reading worth it icon

Add to Goodreads | Buy on Amazon | Buy on B&N

June 4, 2014 - 12:04 pm

tabithasbookblog - I’m beyond excited for this book!! I’ve heard so many good things about it, and this review just makes me want to read it even more! AND. The author is wicked nice which just makes me want to read it even more!

Glad to hear that you ended up enjoying it!

June 4, 2014 - 12:03 am

Alexa S. - I wasn’t quite sure what to make of One Man Guy, but I’m very happy that you wound up enjoying it! It sounds pretty darn cute. Plus, I’m usually a sucker for books about (a) a turning point summer and (b) set in New York City. Will have to check this out at some point!

June 3, 2014 - 10:38 pm

Rebecca - This sounds adorable! I think I’d like this, especially after your lovely review. Apart from bit of preachiness, it looks great. I wonder if my library will get a copy… Glad you enjoyed it!

June 3, 2014 - 7:45 pm

Amy - This DOES sound adorable! I’m really intrigued by the idea that Ethan doesn’t try to question things or make a huge, complicated, CAPSLOCK deal out of his relationship. (Well, I’m assuming that this is what happens because I haven’t read it yet.) The easygoing attitude is pretty special, I think. Ethan sounds like a great dude, and I always love a relationship that seems organic and not deliberately staged. Lots of promising things in this debut!!

June 2, 2014 - 3:23 pm

Mary @ BookSwarm - This sounds too adorable. I feel like I might want to re-experience NYC through their dates after reading it. And I love that the relationship progression is natural, not forced.

June 2, 2014 - 10:47 am

Rosie - This sounds like a really nice and sweet read. I haven’t read anything like that before but there’s no time like the present. Sounds like a nice summer read :)

Rosie x

Estelle: Threatened by Eliot Schrefer

Threatened by Eliot ScreferThreatened by Eliot Schrefer website | tweet ]
Publication Date: February 25, 2014
Publisher: Scholastic
Pages: 288
Target audience: Young adult
Keywords: Africa, orphan, adventure, companionship, chimpanzees, tragedy
Format read: ARC from Publisher via NetGalley! (Thanks!)

Summary: Luc is intrigued by the Professor when he first bumps into him at work. Despite a “misunderstanding”, he takes Luc under his wing as he hopes to study chimps in their natural habitat — the jungle.

At the end of 2014, I fell unexpectedly in love with Eliot Schrefer’s Endangered about a young girl on the run with a bonobo when a violent attack occurs in the Congo. Endangered challenged me; I was instantly out of my comfort zone, knowing next to nothing about the Congo, not even knowing how to pronounce bonobos, much less know what they look like. I didn’t think it was possible to connect so emotionally to a book about a girl, an animal, and a war. But I did. The story was about motherhood, bravery, and connection that went beyond human or animal.

So I shouldn’t have been surprised when Threatened turned out to be a totally different book. I mean, it couldn’t BE the same book so this is really a positive thing because once again Schrefer placed me into an unknown environment with absolutely no idea how it would all end.

One difference? Urgency. A attack is a pretty huge driving force in any book and without it, Threatened read a little slower. Main character Luc is an orphan, living with a guy I could only picture as Fagin from Oliver!. This “gentleman” is not a saint who cares for lost boys but instead takes whatever money they have, keeps track of their “debt”, and allows them to live in the barest of conditions. Miraculously, Luc makes his exit with the help of a visiting professor. Even though Luc tries to steal for him, “Prof” pays off his debt and takes him on as his assistant as he studies chimps in the jungle.

For the first time in a long time, Luc has someone who is investing in him. Teaching, talking, observing. Luc feels possibility in his kinship with Prof, and starts to look beyond the life he thought he knew before. (How his family died, the legend of the “mock man” a.k.a. the chimps.) When it seems like he couldn’t be tested any more, something happens that changes the course of the story and his past threatens to hurt him once again.

Slowly but surely his companions become two chimps: Mango and Drummer. Their relationships are tentative and, sometimes, frustrating but their time in the jungle, learning to survive, brings them closer together and once again, the line between human and animal are blurred as this connection between them is fused.

As Luc assimilates to life in the jungle, I wondered if this would be his life for good. I wondered if he would have the opportunity to befriend other humans. Can the chimps who so obviously care for him make up for the family he lost? Schrefer convinces me, time and time again, that if we are patient, kind, and compassionate that any of these relationships are a possibility. I am amazed how much he can convey between Luc and the chimps because, as you may have guessed, no dialogue is spoken. Just movements, action, and Luc’s thoughts.

If you are looking to try something completely new and connect to this genre in a whole new way, I can’t recommend Schrefer’s books enough. He is a writer who opens me up to brand new ideas and forces me to really listen to the world beyond the city I live in and the world I think I know.

rather be reading worth it icon

Add to Goodreads | Buy on Amazon | Buy on B&N

June 5, 2014 - 8:52 am

Leah - Scholastic is one of my go-to publishers. They know me. Whether I’m in the mood for something light-hearted and fluffy or a humbling story that puts my petty worries into perspective, Scholastic has a book for me.
I have to admit I’ve never heard of either of these books – or even the author! – and now I’m intrigued. Looking through GR, it looks like all of his books are rated pretty high. :) Definitely something I need to check out!

June 3, 2014 - 11:43 pm

Alexa S. - I have yet to read any Schrefer novel, but you make a great case for me to do so in your review! I really do like the fact that his novels sound like nothing I’ve ever read before, and that there’s are animals (in the wild!) involved too. Thanks for always bringing my attention to books like this that might have just gone under the radar without you! <3

June 3, 2014 - 7:50 pm

Amy - I’m so intrigued by this! Books with animals in primary roles sometimes make me super nervous because I’m always deathly afraid that they’ll die, and I don’t handle that well lol. But just reading about Luc’s attachment to the chimps reminds me of Gorillas in the Mist, one of my ultimate tear-jerker movies. (And, you can imagine if you’ve seen it, a big reason why I’m super nervous about Mango and Drummer. Hopefully for no reason whatsoever.) But Africa is one of those settings that I’ve always wanted to see more of in YA; it’s so huge and varied and unknown to me. This book sounds like a great stepping stone to more great books set in Africa!

Magan: The Chapel Wars by Lindsey Leavitt

book cover for The Chapel Wars by Lindsey LeavittThe Chapel Wars by Lindsey Leavitt (twitter | website)
Previously ReviewedSean Griswold’s Head // Going Vintage
Publication Date: May 6, 2014
Publisher: Bloomsbury USA Children’s
Pages: 304
Target Audience: Young Adult
Keywords: family rivalries, loss of a grandparent, secret romance
Format Read: ARC from Publisher via Edelweiss. (Thank you!)

Summary: Not only does Holly inherit her grandfather’s wedding chapel in Las Vegas when he passes away, but she continues the rivalry with the chapel across the parking lot and becomes responsible for saving the chapel when she realizes how much debt they’re in.

 

So you know when you think something is a really awesome concept, but then there’s just a little bit of spark that’s lacking to make it perfect? Essentially, that’s what I walked away from The Chapel Wars feeling. Set in Las Vegas, Holly’s grandfather passes away and she inherits his the wedding chapel he’s lovingly owned and operated. While others (particularly the one across the parking lot) have sold out to commercialize weddings and take theatrics to the extreme, Holly’s grandfather stayed true to his vision of weddings by trying to appeal to the elegant Las Vegas bride. What Holly and her family didn’t realize was the debt her grandfather was in and the race Holly must enter to keep them afloat, all while secretly falling in love with the competition’s grandson and facing an imminent deadline.

The chapel is passed down to Holly because she’s a go-getter who is obsessed with numbers. She’s a problem solver; if anyone’s going to save the chapel, it will be her. Her father is a little spacey and her mother lacks the passion. Holly really struggles with everyone taking her seriously and finding a balance between modernizing the chapel and falling into the money-trap that is Vegas by offering themed weddings and Elvis. The owner of the chapel across the parking lot had a long-withstanding war with her grandfather, and he’d like nothing more than to see Holly’s chapel crash and burn. But his grandson, Dax, enters the picture right around the time of Holly’s grandpa’s funeral. And Holly has a letter she’s been instructed to give him.

Dax and Holly have an instant attraction, but she feels like she’s cheating on her family if she pursues a relationship with him. Thus begins this whirlwind courtship that involves lots of sneaking around, secret dates, and stolen kisses between the chapels. As much as I enjoy seeing characters overcome obstacles, the relationship with Dax and Holly often felt rushed and a little forced. Coupled with the pacing feeling a little off and and an imbalance between the focus on the relationship, chapel, and Holly’s family problems, I always felt intrigued by what the outcome might be, but I didn’t feel invested. (I felt so distanced from Holly that at times I even felt myself not remembering her name.)

I applaud Leavitt for trying to give us more than just a slice of the pie by including multiple aspects of Holly’s life, but some details felt like nibbles when I really wanted to dissect the entire slice. Holly felt distant and difficult to connect to; she’s a very unemotional character who had a lot of barriers that, while intended to keep Dax at a distance, negatively impacted how attached I was to her. When Holly finally begins to loosen up and release some of her tension, her quick judgments felt out-of-character and that really made me feel like her actions were being manipulated for the intention of moving the story along.

If you’re looking to read your first book by Leavitt, I definitely recommend you begin with Sean Griswold’s Head; both Estelle and I have nothing but good things to say for it!

rather be reading borrow from the library icon

Add The Chapel Wars to Goodreads | Buy from Amazon | Buy from Barnes & Noble

June 17, 2014 - 12:59 pm

Brittany @ The Book Addict's Guide - Yes! That’s exactly how I felt too. It was so cute, really enjoyable, and so well done BUT I was missing that little spark to really push it to the amazing status like I felt with Going Vintage. The Vegas setting was so fun and I love that it was so well incorporated into a YA book!
Glad you enjoyed it! :)

June 3, 2014 - 11:39 pm

Alexa S. - You hit the nail on the head with your review, M! While I did wind up enjoying The Chapel Wars overall (which is kind of hard to avoid since it’s got such a fun setting and a few really awesome secondary characters), I do think that there’s room for something to be added. I wish, in particular, that Holly was a more accessible character! This won’t deter me from trying Leavitt’s other novels though :)

June 3, 2014 - 7:53 pm

Amy - I just finished reading this myself, and YES TO ALL THE THINGS. I just loved Sean Griswold’s Head! It is still one of those YA books that surprised me the most with how much it touched me. This book, though, had me feeling much the same as you. I never really clicked with anything. I didn’t feel butterflies or anxiety or tension or anything. Which is a big shame! I love feeling those things! Alas.

June 2, 2014 - 8:09 am

Lori - Too bad you didn’t love this one. It’s hard to beat Sean Griswold’s Head! <3

June 1, 2014 - 4:59 am

Judith - Too bad you felt just okay about this one, M. I’ve heard amazing things about this book, but it’s refreshing to hear from someone who wasn’t head of heels in love with it (because honestly, it doesn’t sound like I would be in love with it either). I do like the concept and setting, but oh, I like characters that FEEL ALL THE THINGS (like, um, I do, haha).

May 28, 2014 - 10:48 pm

Lisa is Busy Nerding - Your closing sentiment was PERFECT for this kid as I haven’t read any Leavitt yet but have this one on my shelf! Better find me a copy of Sean Griswold, first!

Top 10 Tuesday: Not Reviewed but Highly Recommended

top ten tuesday hosted by the broke and the bookish

Oh hey there! Since it’s a freebie week, I thought I would jump in today and BE CREATIVE. I recruited my husband to help me think of a topic. Options ranged from BOOKS WITH MUPPET REFERENCES and BOOKS THAT COULDN’T FIT INTO ANY OTHER TOP 10 LIST. But I settled on this one because it’s true — sharing the blog with Magan means not reviewing every book I read, which is great. I do make the time to read the books she loved + reviewed, reread old favorites, check out other books, etc. There’s no real rhyme or reason to what I pick to review. I make sure I absolutely HAVE SOMETHING I WANT TO SAY and then I just go from there. But sometimes, there just isn’t time or space or whatever reason.

Here’s where today’s list comes in. I hope something catches your eye!

1-2. Time Between Us series by Tamara Ireland Stone

For awhile, I had quite the aversion to books that were not contemporary. I know it was just fear of the unknown, and gosh, I am so glad I let go of all of that and checked out this series after seeing Tamara at a reading. The music references, the romance, the family aspect… this series kept me up WAY late.

Rather Be Reading Buy It Icon

3. The Miseducation of Cameron Post by Emily Danforth

An intense story where the main character is forced to change who she is. I read this at the end of the 2012 and remember sitting on my couch, completely riveted but all the emotions and intense characters. The book is very long but spans a ton of time, and is worth picking up. (When is Emily writing another book?)

rather be reading worth it icon

4. The Anatomy of a Boyfriend by Daria Snadowsky

I reviewed Snadowsky’s second book, THE ANATOMY OF A SINGLE GIRL, having no idea that it was a companion to this book. A few things were spoiled sure, but I loved reading about Dom’s senior year, her first time falling in love, and her (difficult because of high pressure) relationship with her supportive parents as she sets forth to make big decisions like picking a college and choosing to live away from home or not. It was definitely authentic to my own senior year experiences.

rather be reading worth it icon

5. Alienated by Melissa Launders

I know… Estelle and a book about aliens? What is happening?! It’s true, folks. I totally loved this one. The chemistry between the two characters is great, I loved Cara’s tenacity and loyalty, and the world that Melissa dreamed up was so so so fantastic. I read it, immediately lent it to my coworker, and put it on my shopping list. I also cannot WAIT for book 2.

Rather Be Reading Buy It Icon

6. Past Perfect by Leila Sales

The LOVELY Hannah from So Obsessed With gifted me this one for my birthday + I read it pretty soon after I got it. Whenever someone is looking for a great book about BEST FRIENDS … this is one of my recommendations. Hands down. The relationship between the main character and her best friend is not perfect (in the best way). This is why it felt so real, and why I couldn’t put it down. (Plus there’s a swoony romance and an interesting setting — historical village!)

rather be reading worth it icon

7. Dr. Bird’s Advice for Sad Poets by Evan Roskos

Um, I have to scream about this book from the rooftops. I am so ashamed that I haven’t. Ugh. Terrible, Estelle. Terrible. This book made me laugh, it made me cry, and I just wanted to hug it. (Instead, I just passed it to my mom to read.) A main character who is battling abusive parents, his runaway sister, and falling in love at school. It was so charming and so realistic. Read it. Now. (I am thinking about ways to plug this book in the future… right now.)

Rather Be Reading Buy It Icon

8. Uses for Boys by Erica Lorriane Scheidt

I know this book left a lot of readers up in arms over it. WHAT DID IT ALL MEAN? But I thought it was heartbreakingly beautiful and the writing was so poetic — I wanted to just fall into it. Yes, the main character does latch on to guys. She does. But, like everyone in the world, she was trying to find HER home HER happy place in many unfortunate situations. I read it in close to one sitting and wow, it totally blew me away.

Rather Be Reading Buy It Icon

9. Kiss the Morning Star by Elissa Janine Hoole

A road trip, best friends, self-discovery. A very unique take on all three of these things; so gorgeously written and so well-done. I bought a copy for Magan right after I finished. (I think I borrowed mine from the library.) I think that should tell you all you need to know right there.

Rather Be Reading Buy It Icon

10. Freefall by Mindi Scott

Thanks to the awesome Ginger for bringing Mindi Scott into my life; both of her books are fantastic but I’m spotlighting Freefall today. I remember devouring this story of a boy dealing with the death of his best friend and slowly trying to change what is expected of him within his family and his town. Mindi does a great job of dissecting the more difficult situations in life, and she really wowed me with this one.

Okay! A quick recap:

Rather Be Reading Buy It Icon

rather be reading worth it icon

TTT Worth It Not Reviewed

A few thoughts… do you share reviews for every book that you read? How do you decide?
Any that you want to recommend to me?? I’d love to hear them!

Thanks for stopping in! Happy Tuesday!

June 2, 2014 - 10:19 pm

Alexa S. - Oh, I loved the Time Between Us series! It gave me lots of feelings, in the best way, and I’m so glad I wound up reading them. I also got reminded that I want to read Alienated and Kiss the Morning Star, thanks to your post, and I’m thrilled you enjoyed them both!

June 1, 2014 - 5:07 am

Judith - Oooh, this is a good topic for a TTT! I wish that I read enough to write little reviews like this, but alas, I’m a slow reader and I review pretty much everything I read. I’ve only read Anatomy of a Boyfriend, but I totally enjoyed it. I think it’s great that it’s so open about sexuality and the transition from high school to college. And Past Perfect and Kiss the Morning Star are about best friends? MUST HAVE!

May 29, 2014 - 9:36 pm

maria helena - Great list! I’m gonna have to add some of these to my tbr list.

May 28, 2014 - 4:40 pm

Alexa - I have a great co-blogger on my blog but I still like to review almost all of the books that I read even if I didn’t like them that much or have strong feelings one way or the other.

May 27, 2014 - 8:58 pm

Lucy - Love this! I think this topic should be in the regular TTT rotation. Since it’s impossible to review everything, this at least gives the book some acknowledgement.

I didn’t review Dr. Bird or Uses for Boys either but enjoyed them both very much! Kiss the Morning Star and Time Between Us are books I keep meaning to read.

May 27, 2014 - 7:53 pm

Cecelia - What a fun list idea! I review maybe 1/4 of the books I read, so this would be a fun pick for the next freebie TTT. Also: I haven’t read any of these books. Eeek!

May 27, 2014 - 3:44 pm

Rachel - I’ve only been blogging since March, but to-date I’ve done a review of every book I’ve read. I’m going to start doing DNF reviews and a collection of mini-reviews for some books, as I find some I have a lot to say and for others I struggle to do s full review, so I’m going to pull them together into the one. Great idea for a topic!

My TTT: http://confessionsofabookgeek.wordpress.com/2014/05/27/top-ten-tuesday-remembering-alfie/

May 27, 2014 - 3:17 pm

Jess @ Gone with the Words - I love this topic because I think we all must have some of these. I definitively don’t review every book I read, but the ones I seem to especially skip are the last books in series. I have reviewed them but it never seems right. I have a lot of these in my TBR so I’ll have to be sure and make time for them. :)

May 27, 2014 - 11:24 am

Laura - WOW! I haven’t read any of these. Thank you for these recommendations!

There are a few books I’ve read but haven’t reviewed, mostly because I didn’t have a place to review them (blog, Goodreads, didn’t bother with retail sites) or knew how to review. But I’m always recommending Tana French’s Dublin Murder Squad series, just about everything written by Sarah Dessen and Jodi Picoult, and obviously Harry Potter. Nowadays, if I don’t post a review, it’s because I literally do not have the words. I can only rate it, and it’s usually off the charts!

My TTT

May 27, 2014 - 9:39 am

Ginger @ GReads! - What a great topic idea! Since I’m not the fastest reader, I typically review most of what I read. However, there are a few that slip by and never make it on the blog. If I can’t finish a book, then I don’t review it. There have been some steamy romances that I read for pure pleasure and don’t review either. I like that you mentioned Uses for Boys in your list today. I remember talking about this book in length with you during & after I read it. I know lots of people hated it, but it was comforting to know that we shared a lot of the same opinions about it. And Yay for Mindi Scott! She will always be on my auto-buy list :)

Estelle: Played by Liz Fichera

Played by Liz FicheraPlayed by Liz Fichera ( web | tweet )
Part of the HOOKED series / companion novel.
Publication Date: May 27, 2014
Publisher: Harlequin Teen
Pages: 352
Target audience: Young adult
Keywords: racial discrimination, brothers/sisters, unrequited love
Format read: ARC from Publisher via NetGalley. (Thanks!)

Summary: At a teen leadership retreat, Sam and Riley are unluckily paired together. Sam’s hope of getting their time together over with quickly doesn’t come true when Riley gets hurt and he has to think quickly to get them both into safety. To pay him back for saving her, Riley agrees to help Sam get the girl of his dreams back — even if she’s the girl that her own brother is currently in love with.

After a lot of serious / emotional books, I chose Played to read next because I was in the market for something light. Here’s how it fared for me:

Pros:

  • Yay companion novels! I didn’t read HOOKED (Magan read + reviewed it last year) so it was nice to start fresh in a new story with a few references to Fred and Ryan’s story. It’s why I like Miranda Kenneally’s Hundred Oaks series so much!
  • The tension: Sam and Riley do not like each other at first. Not even a little bit. Sam doesn’t like Riley by association — she’s the sister of the guy who stole the love of his life. Riley doesn’t like Sam’s attitude and think he’s making fun of her the first time they communicate during their leadership retreat. She’s used to being in charge, and that’s when she gets the both of them in trouble. Things heat up between the two pretty quickly, but they resist oh-so-much and the build up is very steamy.
  • Sam is a good guy. He loves his family (though his relationship with his parents isn’t perfect), he’s super smart (scholarships in his future), and he’s dependable even when he doesn’t want to be. He’s there for his friends, and finds himself unable to resist Riley, especially when she needs him the most (which is a lot). I genuinely liked him. Plus he rides a motorcycle! That was pretty darn sexy.
  • Memorable supporting characters: Even though Ryan is (rightfully) downgraded to the supporting cast in this book, I really liked him a lot; he’s a good brother. Then there’ s Mr. Beringer (Riley and Ryan’s dad). Sadly, fathers don’t get the best rep in books but Mr. B has some key moments where I went “aww”. Then there is Martin, who felt like Sam’s brother and not just his best friend. I admired his honesty and his loyalty to Sam — especially later in the book.

Cons:

  • Riley: As someone who is practically perfect in every way and expected to be that way all the time (especially compared to her brother who was always getting in trouble), Riley is supposed to transform into a bit of a wild child in Played. I just didn’t buy it. If we had seen more of her as “the good girl” and there was  a distinct difference between before vs. after — I would have grasped it better. To go a step farther, I’m not sure what Riley had to complain about in her life. Her problems didn’t matter to me, especially because her only reason for acting out was because of her brother? She seemed more bratty than someone who was trying to figure herself out.
  • Leadership retreat: I was SO excited when I read the synopsis and saw this was a part of the book. So different! Except… we weren’t there very long. That was disappointing.
  • Playing Cupid: I get that Sam had a thing for Fred for awhile and he was bummed when they didn’t get together. Their friendship hadn’t been the same in a long time but it confused me that the main character of this book was trying to undue a majority of the action in the first book. Thoughts I had: 1) If Riley succeeded, we could dismiss Hooked entirely. 2) Duh. Riley is totally not going to pull this off so it will all be wasted time where the two main characters get closer. (Can you guess what happened?)
  • Crazy unbelievable events: Um, I think I could have accepted how insane things got for these two if there was more development in other areas of the book (especially character wise).
  • Girl friendship: Drew is Riley’s best gal pal and I’m sad their relationship didn’t get pushed to the forefront more. I think it really needed to be, especially toward the end.

Final thoughts: Unfortunately, I wanted to like Played more than I did. Even all the chemistry in the world couldn’t make me ignore how much I didn’t understand Riley or her motivation to act the way she did. Sam was a great guy, and I was totally rooting for him but, all in all, Played was underwhelming and had far too many holes for me to fully enjoy it.

Rather Be Reading Skip It Icon

Add to Goodreads | Buy on Amazon | Buy on B&N

June 2, 2014 - 9:50 pm

Alexa S. - I must say that Played sounded a whole lot better than Hooked, and I was nearly convinced to give this author another try. However, it really sounds like there was something missing in this story, like potential that went to waste. I still do think the romance sounds pretty cute though, so I have to give her that!

May 27, 2014 - 3:22 pm

Jess @ Gone with the Words - UGH! There’s nothing worse than when a book is made to sound really good in the synopsis only to let us down overall. I’m sorry this one didn’t live up. It doesn’t sound like I’d have a good time reading it either with the issues you had with it. :/